My mom is a "neat freak", which I have no problem with, but when things aren't tidy to her requirements, she takes her frustration out on the family. She yells and criticises my sisters and it's really hard to take. I hate seeing other people hurt. And it's all made somehow worse by the fact that because I've somehow crossed a line and they (my parents) know that I'm not under their control, they never yell at or criticise me. And my sister's picked up my mom's habit, and is continually criticising her younger sister. And I have tried for four years to try and stop all of this but it's hopeless.
I'm just wondering how I can deal with this, because it's one of the most stressful things I go through every day.
Last edited by Kallisti : 23-09-2007 at 02:59 AM.
Reason: adding "advice?"
"When I was a little kid, my mother told me not to stare into the sun, so when I was six I did..."
have you tried talking to your mom and older sister about they feel, and how they see it affecting you and the younger sister? How do your sisters feel about the constant criticism?
if talking to your mum doesn't help, i think the best you can really do is to be supportive of your sisters and treat them as you wish your mother would. as the older sister they look up to you just as they do your mum and if at least one of their influences can be a positive one they won't feel so surrounded by negativity. when my parents are nasty to my siblings i try and be the opposite and be someone they can feel safe around so that they know that it's not them that's the problem. you know what i mean?
as for your sister who is picking up your mum's habits, i think you should directly talk to her about that. ask her how she feels when she's yelled at and ask if she wants to make her little sister feel the same way.
i think in a situation like this it will be great to know that someone is looking out for them and that it's not their fault when your mother gets frustrated. love > criticism any day, just be loving. hang in there.
well, i have sown untidy furrows 'cross my soul,
but I am still a coward,
content to see my garden grow so sweet & full
of someone else's flowers.
People can become like what they respond to (or hate). Mum is sowing her hostile identity into sisters. It can be a dog eat dog world like that. A boss yells at Dad, Dad yells at Mum, Mum yells at the kids and the kids beat the dog (or SI).
There is generally a degree of cowardice involved as well. A lot of people are weak before the strong and strong before the weak . Mum might be one of those sorts who is nice to people outside the house and/or gives in to intimidation and then transfers the suppressed hostility to the kids who are "safe" targets. Parents often use their kids as a psychic dumping ground and the average home has a lot of sick undercurrents that often show up in the kids who then look like the problem and get branded by pill-n-bill shrinks while witchy Mum gets off.
As to solution..keep in mind all bullies are cowards. People who want to upset you count on your return hostility to keep from seeing themselves. They take their strength from getting high knocking people down. If Mum tries to upset you see it as a game of psychic "hot potato" where your emotional response is needed for her to transfer her hostility.
If you can see what she is doing and not over react and/or hate her for it she will begin to feel self conscious about what she is doing. Its like telling a dirty joke and nobody laughs. If you were really stout you could calmly say to mum that she is upsetting people as a way to feel better for herself and that its destructive. You would probably get a banshee on your hands with that though so you need to be ready for it. If you can handle it then the tables get turned and instead of you overreacting to mum and fearing her mum would react to the patience in you and feel self conscious. The guilt of that usually ends up with that sort trying to be extra nice instead of extra mean.
So, if you dont get hostile and upset back, the people trying to knock you down to get a lift for themselves will feel self conscious and exposed and learn to leave you alone. Its ok to feel the hurt feelings and to be afraid but its hating the parent that turns into guilt and self doubt/loathing etc. and costs you your native resilience. Keep merry eyes twinkling and mum will self-destruct in her transfers.
The problem is that I have talked to all these people involved, and words just don't cut it. The older sister simply refuses to listen to me at all, I'll ask her to please stop criticising D (name changed), but she just keeps on doing so.
My mom I've talked to a lot over the years, because she's always been going off on temper tantrums. My dad doesn't get mad and cause her to get mad, it's basically when her plans don't work she gets mad. And by plans, I mean how tidy the house is kept, whether we go places on time, our appearence in public...etc. Anything starts getting out of shape for her perfect idea of the world, and she starts ranting and raving.
She's said that she's really working on it, and that she's made a lot of improvement. I don't know whether that's even remotely true. Unless you stop or try to when you see that your anger is pointless and hurting other people, then I don't really believe that she's trying.
It's like I'll try to point it out to her. I'll point out her illogic and her hypocrisy and how she's not doing any good, and instead of actually paying attention to what I say, she'll just start ranting more.
I have four sisters, A, B, C, D (names changed), from oldest to youngest. (C yells at D.)
A is casual, and leaves areas messy. She also can be fussy about her appearence or about other things and is occassionally the reason we're late getting somewhere. My mom gets frustrated with her a lot (mad at her a lot).
This morning, as they were getting ready for church, my mom for some reason can't decide what to wear. And so, SHE's making them late. And on her way out to the car I told her that it needed gas (I was going to fill it tomorrow, because I didn't know they were taking my car) and so she immediately transfers her anger to me and to life in general, saying, "Well, great! Now we're really going to be late!"
She totally abandons compassion or reason just so that she can continue being angry.
"When I was a little kid, my mother told me not to stare into the sun, so when I was six I did..."
"My dad doesn't get mad and cause her to get mad, it's basically when her plans don't work she gets mad. And by plans, I mean how tidy the house is kept, whether we go places on time, our appearence in public...etc. Anything starts getting out of shape for her perfect idea of the world, and she starts ranting and raving."
Keep in mind one other source of frustration for moms is when Dad's sort of meekly float away into the background (becoming like one of the kids) and leave mother in charge of everything. A willful and controlling mom can want to be in control of everything but then be 2x as bitter when they get it. Truth is your Dad should be addressing the unhealthy stress mom brings but he's probably afraid to rock the boat and risk losing Moms support. Meek dads and King Kong with Bloomers on Moms is a common (but ignored) problem often at root of identity issues imo.
I bet Mom was probably harassed growing up as well. Shes compensating for her emotionality by trying to control everything.
I just remembered the football team out your way is called the "Badgers" - I had assumed it was for the animal lol.
Hi.
That must be a really uncomfortable situation to be in. I agree with what's been said about trying to be as loving and as positive as possible around your sisters. Just keep trying to get across to them that this is their mother's problem and that she really does care about them very much, that's just hidden underneath her anger a lot of the time but it doesn't mean it's not there.
Have you any idea if there is anything in your mother's past which causes her to get so anxious about everything? Could you try approaching her from an angle where you say you acknowledge that she may not have any control over how she reacts but it's really hurting the family and it can't be pleasant for her either. Would counselling be something she would consider? Sometimes the softly-softly approach can get through.
You say your dad doesn't get mad or cause her to get mad. Is he an active parent? Does he intervene when your mum is being irrational towards your sisters? If not could that be something you could discuss with him? I'm sure it would really help your sisters to have an actively loving parent around whenever your mum is being hostile towards them.
I would say that the most important thing you can do is just try and increase their self-worth whenever you can.
I really hope things get better for you and your family.
Kiran
xx
"My dad doesn't get mad and cause her to get mad, it's basically when her plans don't work she gets mad. And by plans, I mean how tidy the house is kept, whether we go places on time, our appearence in public...etc. Anything starts getting out of shape for her perfect idea of the world, and she starts ranting and raving."
Keep in mind one other source of frustration for moms is when Dad's sort of meekly float away into the background (becoming like one of the kids) and leave mother in charge of everything. A willful and controlling mom can want to be in control of everything but then be 2x as bitter when they get it. Truth is your Dad should be addressing the unhealthy stress mom brings but he's probably afraid to rock the boat and risk losing Moms support. Meek dads and King Kong with Bloomers on Moms is a common (but ignored) problem often at root of identity issues imo.
I bet Mom was probably harassed growing up as well. Shes compensating for her emotionality by trying to control everything.
I just remembered the football team out your way is called the "Badgers" - I had assumed it was for the animal lol.
Actually, it is called that for the animal.
You're right about most of what you said.
I don't know whether she gets mad at dad for 'floating away', but I don't really think so. He usually either joins her in 'getting the kids to listen' or he notices that she's out of control and just gets out of the way.
And yes, I'd say that it's caused identity issues for me to have my parents that way. Not the only reason for the issues, but a reason for them.
And I see myself now being extremely cooperative with my girlfriend. In what may be an unhealthy way. I don't feel any need to control her, and even if I did I wouldn't want to, but it scares me a little that I totally do everything I can to make her happy no matter what. Codependancy has always been a problem for me, and its especially bad because she lives 700 miles away from me, and will at least until the spring.
It drives me nuts to be so lonely, and to not know if she's okay (emotionally or even physically -- I wound up SHing last night just to stop the bad thoughts that she was/was going to be hurt or killed). And I'm stuck somewhere and I don't know anything and life is crushing me...
...sorry. I'm not doing well right now. I'll stop now.
"When I was a little kid, my mother told me not to stare into the sun, so when I was six I did..."