RYL Forums


Forum Jump
Post New Thread  Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Old 27-08-2015, 10:36 AM   #1
Uno
 
Uno's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2015
House-mate issues... Caught in the middle!

Hi all,

Apologies for the length of this in advance.

I won't lie, I did join specifically to see if anyone could help with this issue as it's been bothering me all night and causing my two other housemates to argue incessantly. However, you all seem very friendly so I promise to try and participate in future!

The issue lies with our current need for a new housemate. At the moment, there's me and another guy, we'll call him Jack, who is dating the third housemate, a girl, Jill. We're all early 20s and we get on very well for the most part. I've known them for about a year; they've been dating for about two I think.

The house we've moved to is a three bed, and currently the couple share a room, leaving us with a room to rent.

We currently seem to have two contenders for the room:

1) A girl of similar age who contacted me after seeing the ad we put online. She's lovely; I think we would all get on very well. I also think having another girl in the mix would be a much better dynamic for the house as a whole. She visited to view yesterday, and made a fantastic first impression; unfortunately Jill wasn't in at the time so that's a slight spanner in the works as she will need to meet her... And the viewer came all the way from London UK (2hrs away by train!) to view. I guess we'll cross that bridge later though.

2) Jill's cousin, a guy, again the same age as us. And this is where it gets tricky: she really wants him to move in. Only problem is, Jack doesn't like him. I'm someone who tries hard to keep an open mind, but the thing that's made me worry is that before she told us that she wanted her cousin to move in, Jill gave us a few reasons why he shouldn't move in. One of those reasons was historical drug use... Eeep.
In essence, she changed her mind in the space of about two days. Also, Jill showed us both the texts from her cousin regarding moving in... I would be lying if I said I didn't view a lot of those texts as guilt trips (eg., "The only way I'll be able to get a new job is if I move into your house."

In addition, this chap is coming round tonight, probably expecting to get the room (judging from some other messages) but I can already feel myself preferring the girl that viewed. I know, I know... Open mind. *deep breaths*

The issues here as I see are as follows:
1) Jill will be annoyed for weeks if me and Jack go against her wishes and say we don't want her cousin to move in. She's also played the 'he's family' card, which I feel is irrelevant if we don't get on with him... But maybe I'm wrong. A similar thing happened with one of my friends a while ago who needed somewhere to stay, and I offered them my place, only to be met with a "It's a bad idea... This needs to be a house decision... etc" from Jill. So in that instance I backed off and found them a hostel. I know family is a step up from friend but in reality, it's the same scenario this time, but now the shoe is on the other foot, suddenly it's all fine.
2) If we say we prefer the girl, Jill is likely to say no to her out of spite.
3) If we do give in, and let her cousin stay, I have a feeling things will deteriorate between all of us, as from what I can see, he just isn't our 'type'. But, Jill will be content for now.
4) If he does stay, past experience Jack has had with this guy suggests that the guy will back Jill up in an argument; effectively splitting the house down the middle every time there's an altercation.
5) We've tried to talk to Jill about it, but she just becomes argumentative and storms off without really attempting a proper discussion. *sigh.* Humans.

I feel like Jill won't let up on this. But if her cousin doesn't stay, I'm not really sure if she'll agree to anyone else... I imagine we can't just overrule her as the majority and I wouldn't want to... But I don't know what options we have! We do really need a housemate!

Really appreciate you reading all that, thank you.

What would you do?

Uno is offline   Reply With Quote
3 Hugs Given By :
Old 27-08-2015, 11:21 AM   #2
griddlebone
Head of Chat/Forum Mod.
 
griddlebone's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: London.
I am currently:

Overrule her, seriously....majority rules. If you're going to be unhappy and Jack is going to be unhappy just to keep Jill happy it wont work. Plus having someones family member there will make you feel like you can't ask them to do their share of cleaning etc. I say get the girl to move in, Jill will get over it and might make a new friend with the girl!




There are times to stay put, and what you want will come to you.
But there are times to go out into the world and find such a thing for yourself.
I aint no abacus but you can count on me.


griddlebone is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 27-08-2015, 05:05 PM   #3
PoppyLove
 
PoppyLove's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2015
Location: USA
I am currently:

I would point out the instance where you tried to offer a room to her friend, and say that clearly a precedent has been set that house majority decides and exceptions aren't made for relations or relationships.

Then, be honest. Tell her that his history is concerning to you, and that you really think he would be a bad fit for the house. Explain that the girl who interviewed was fantastic, and that you're certain Jill would like her too and that it truly would be the best solution for everyone.

Best of luck! I lived with a girl who sounds a lot like Jill (we'd been friends since grade school) and it can be a nasty experience, even during the good times. Needless to say, we're not friends anymore, but that was her choice.

PoppyLove is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 01-09-2015, 09:27 AM   #4
Uno
 
Uno's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2015

Thank you all for replying, I really appreciate it! There are a lot of points I can think about here.

Developments are as follows:
- Jill is concerned that we 'don't care' about her happiness (despite her being in the minority)
- She has threatened to leave if we pick the 'random girl' over her cousin (possibly heading in the direction of blackmail...)
- She agrees her cousin isn't the easiest person to get on with, but still feels we should be more accommodating because 'he's family'.

The reason he's so desperate to move in is (we think) because he's generally been quite sheltered; it's an easy option for him to move with a family member who he already knows.

At this point, it seems like no one can win!

I've already said my peace and tried to help her understand where I'm coming from and she's done the same. I've now passed the decision back to Jack, who is now considering going for the cousin just to keep Jill happy (not something I agree with, but also not something I will argue with if that's what he thinks is best!).

I imagine we'll discuss it again tonight; I'll talk about the thing you've mentioned and see where it goes.

Thank you ever so much for you help :)

Uno is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Members Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Censor is ON
Forum Jump


Sea Pink Aroma
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:13 PM.