Hi Hillary,
From the sound of it, your father is doing a technique similar to when nurses give SI'ers fresh blades, or drug abusers clean needles - it sounds like he's trying to be prevenatitve rather than interventative. Rather than risk her falling into an awfully drunken slump, or ending up with liver disease today, for example, he's trying to limit the damage as much as possible.
This is a two-way path. One the one hand, it does mean that she would drink less than she was otherwise drinking, and your father could feel like he had some control over the problem, but on the other hand, it has the risk of sending the message to your mum that drinking alcohol in such large quantities is not only acceptable, but it's safe, too.
Why not try talking to your father about it? You could just mention what you've said here, that you're concerned about how it's really going to help her?
If it helps at all, I've been in a similar situation with my father; he was an alcoholic, as was his father before him, and it took a car crash and an eighteen month driving ban before he realised that something had to change.
For further reading, you could try looking at
Coping with Alcoholism [link], which is a good site, albeit rather too simplistic.
For further support, there is also
Alcoholics Anonymous [link] and
]Alcohol Concern [link]
Good luck, and take care.
Jo xo