um, I figured this could go here since its where the piercing thread is, if im wrong i apologize.
I was wondering, like.... how some people get tats done over when unsatisfied with the original... maybe this can be done with scars? work them into a scarification piece? I have a friend who is not a self harmer but he has one hell of a scarification piece on his back...
and basically i was wondering if anybody has or would consider something like this.. like artistic scarification to cover si scars. or would the process possibly break recovery and cause relapse? I do not consider this type of body modification to me self harm even if one does it themselves as opposed to having a professional do it, since the intent is completely different (pain is the side effect, not the goal)
I've heard conflicting things on whether or not a scar can be tattooed over so i was kind of thinking that scarification would be a more sure bet as cover up, provided it didnt trigger into relapse? thoughts?
also, if you think this is a good idea and you want to do it READ UP ON IT FIRST or hire someone skilled at it (some tattoo artists will do scarification too) and like with piercings be sure to keep things sterile. scarification is much more prone to infection than tats and needs a very high level of aftercare for it to turn out right
Last edited by squirrelspit : 10-10-2010 at 06:10 PM.
Reason: removing picture as there have been lots of complaints about it.
Half Psychotic Sick Hypnotic We sat and waited for the sea
To stretch out so that we could disappear
Into the endlessness of blue Into the horror of the truth We are far less than we knew
ive thought about it before, however ive always come to the conclusion that tattoos just look better. thats a personal opinion but looking at your example.. i just cant imagine why you'd want that over getting it tattooed on.
Last edited by The 666th Pope : 03-10-2010 at 05:09 PM.
Scars over more scars seems very... counter productive. I'd rather have pretty, colourful art over a scar than, well... another scar... don't see the point.
DILLIGAF
"it’s when you’re acting selflessly, that you are at your bravest"
- Four.
♥
Some tattoo artists will tattoo over scars, provided they are the right kind and they have been healed for a year or two. Some people try to work the scar into the design rather than tattoo over it.
Scarification is a bit hit of miss from what I know of it. There's no guarantee that you will actually scar in the way you have 'designed' it to, if at all. And designs have to be large and undetailed. There's also that if you are white, you won't really see it.
I saw an article on the TV one time about this girl who had been a self-harmer and, once she felt she was 'free' from SI, had the shape of a koi fish done with scarification on her arm - it actually looked really good once finished, and the SI scars quite naturally and neatly 'fitted' into the design as part of the scales.
While, obviously, there's no 100% guarantee of scarification designs going the way they are planned - neither is there with tattooing over scars as the scar tissue is more dense and the tattoo can 'bleed' if the tissue doesn't hold the colour correctly. Although that can happen in healthy undamaged tissue too so it's doesn't necessarily mean that you can't tattoo over scars.
I agree with the OP though, that it wouldn't be a method of SI, but rather a way of modifying your body with pain being a side effect.
For those doubts that swirl all around us
For those lives that tear at the seams
We know… we’re not what we’ve seen
For this dance we’ll move with each other
There ain’t no other step than one foot
Right in front of the other
There are some beautiful scarifications out there, that isnt the nicest scarification i have seen. Depending on the design it can be more beautiful in my eyes than a tattoo.
Scars over more scars seems very... counter productive. I'd rather have pretty, colourful art over a scar than, well... another scar... don't see the point.
Point would be to hide the fact that the original scar was from SH. The reason I was considering this is because I have quite a few friends who are tattoo artists and they do not seem to agree on whether or not its ok to attempt to tattoo a scar. They do all agree however, that the results are unpredictable on some types of scars, so it would be quite a gamble.
Another reason would be for the texture, in reading about this type of mod one story caught my eye where there was a woman who had a scarification done instead of a tat so that her blind husband could "see" it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by The One Who
Some people try to work the scar into the design rather than tattoo over it.
I'd completely forgotten to consider that too, good point.
Choosing any type of body mod should be thoroughly thought out in advance which is why I ask opinions of this, you may be able to see some point or disadvantage or another option that I otherwise may have not considered. You've given good points why tats are better than scarification in general, but nobody yet has said whether or not they believe scarification may result in relapse due to the higher amount of pain and blood involved, as opposed to tattoos. I'd really like to hear peoples thoughts on that aspect rather than the aesthetic aspect of one vs. the other.
Half Psychotic Sick Hypnotic We sat and waited for the sea
To stretch out so that we could disappear
Into the endlessness of blue Into the horror of the truth We are far less than we knew
Some tattoo artists will tattoo over scars, provided they are the right kind and they have been healed for a year or two. Some people try to work the scar into the design rather than tattoo over it.
this.
at the moment i'm in conversation & designs over my legs works, i want them tattooed to incorporate the scars, but once the scars are faded (n like 12 years or something) the tattoo will still look attractive.
There are some beautiful scarifications out there, that isnt the nicest scarification i have seen. Depending on the design it can be more beautiful in my eyes than a tattoo.
Yeah, that one isn't the best example. I'm not sure how it looks now, the pic is from a year ago and he has had some more work on it since then, and some tattooing with it. birds on the tree or something like that
Half Psychotic Sick Hypnotic We sat and waited for the sea
To stretch out so that we could disappear
Into the endlessness of blue Into the horror of the truth We are far less than we knew
this.
at the moment i'm in conversation & designs over my legs works, i want them tattooed to incorporate the scars, but once the scars are faded (n like 12 years or something) the tattoo will still look attractive.
Surely whether it would cause a relapse is entirely personal? Depending on where it was done it might help prevent any further damage so as not to ruin the design. I'd also assume that the person would be recovered enough so that any blood or scars or whatever else wouldn't trigger them?
I, personally, don't understand how seeing blood or scars triggers people since self-harm for me is a very personal emotional thing. But obviously for others it's different.
Point would be to hide the fact that the original scar was from SH. The reason I was considering this is because I have quite a few friends who are tattoo artists and they do not seem to agree on whether or not its ok to attempt to tattoo a scar. They do all agree however, that the results are unpredictable on some types of scars, so it would be quite a gamble.
Another reason would be for the texture, in reading about this type of mod one story caught my eye where there was a woman who had a scarification done instead of a tat so that her blind husband could "see" it.
that might not work though, the actual wound they cause for scarification isn't that big & your body might not scar from that wound, it depends on how well you heal and how clean/dirty etc.
you may not actually end up with a hypertrophic scar from the wound caused, in fact, you might not end up with any scars, leaving a patchy design.
tattooing over scars is a gamble, but providing it's not a heavy black shape it will generally cover well.
you need to shop around though, a good artist will be able to go over your scars or implicate them in a design & a good artist will do touchups for free.