Ta-dah!
http://rylrecommends.blogspot.co.uk/
One (hopefully) easy to read list featuring all the anime we have collectively recommended. If you would like to add any comments to any series already on the list just write them in this thread and I will add them to the list. Also I will update the list whenever someone talks about a new series :)
Let me know if anything needs changing or if you think something would work better