RYL Forums

RYL Forums (https://www.recoveryourlife.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Support and Advice (https://www.recoveryourlife.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=27)
-   -   meds without therapy (https://www.recoveryourlife.com/forum/showthread.php?t=14277)

hldunbar452 20-08-2007 08:38 PM

meds without therapy
 
Is there anyway to get antidepressants without doing the counsling part?

DownSabeana 20-08-2007 08:48 PM

maybe if you go to your like... family pratice dr. (thats what mine is called)
the dr. you go to when your sick... and maybe if you tell them you cant talk to a counsler or whatever they might try to find a good med for you... but some wont... its worth a try tho

of the lore 20-08-2007 10:23 PM

I honestly have no idea. :] My med guy won't give me meds unless I go to a therapist. But the therapy part isn't so bad. You could just give it a try, maybe.

Puppet Strings 20-08-2007 10:27 PM

Can I ask why you're not wanting to see a counsellor?
Anti-depressants are usually accompanied with professional help of some sort, and sometimes the professional help is enough to help some, without needing the drugs.
All you can really do is go to your GP, and express your feelings, but I doubt that he'd be willing to give you anti-depressants without any sort of help along side them. Usually, anti-depressants are given after someone has had a few sessions, and not just dished out.
Also, it is often said that anti-depressants work best alongside professional support, and anti-depressants just help the here and now, they won't solve any issues as to how you feel in the long term, and whatnot.
Take care,
Rach x

~invisible~girl~ 20-08-2007 10:39 PM

Yes. Most GPs will prescribe antidepressants to people without them being in counseling, as will many psychiatrists. My sister is on antidepressants but not in therapy. The first time they were prescribed by a psychiatrist, and I think now her pediatrician is prescribing them but I'm not sure.

That said, you should really consider counseling. While many doctors prescribe antidepressants as a sort of a quick fix without counseling, the best results usually come from a combination of counseling and medication.

hldunbar452 20-08-2007 11:06 PM

Rach-

I went to a counsler for about a year and it ended when they decided to call the police without telling me first. (A friend called them saying that she was worried about me) So i felt very betrayed by them. I tried to find a new therapist this past week, but i got the whole "im sorry i cant help you" because the center doesnt have afterhour care in case u had a crisis or something. I know that i need to be on antidepressants really badly but i just dont want to start over. I feel like im repeating the same things over and over, just to different people.

Mimsy 20-08-2007 11:37 PM

I had meds without counselling. That said... my case wasnt very severe. I just needed a little helping hand to keep me on top of things I guess.
So it does happen, but she did say that I may have to see a counsellor if it continues for a while.
Take Care

Beatrix 21-08-2007 12:15 AM

Usually, meds coupled with counseling is the most effective combination, but from what you wrote, I can certainly understand why you're hesitant to go back to it. Still, don't totally forget about it either. Don't be afraid to keep looking for a good counselor in the meantime - they do exist, I promise you.

The reason a combination is usually recommended is that medication will treat the symptoms, but not always the root cause. Counseling can also help us to really thing about and modify our behaviours and thought patterns to control depression and anxiety. As an example: I have a friend who has quite a severe chemical imbalance, but he won't see a counselor; he believes the meds will control the issue. However, his bahviours have become ingrained, and he acts very much the same as he did when he wasn't medicated. now that he is attempting to come off his meds, he has no idea how to control his condition, whereas he would have a plan had he seen a good counselor.

I'm not saying this is the case with you, and perhaps medication alone will be a big help for you. All I'm saying is don't totally discount the idea; just keep it in the back of your mind and think on it. Whatever you decide to do, I wish you the very best!! <3

Ami 21-08-2007 08:35 AM

i thought i could do the same. I said to my psych "i would rather take a little pill to make it all go away than talk about things i dont even know"

Im on meds, then he decided that i should see a see a CPN for extra support, so i will see how that goes today.

i think it would be a good idea to use a combo of them both personally.
take care x

black_vortex 21-08-2007 01:06 PM

From my growing knowledge of psych (as a student) and someone with many issues (SI, eating etc) i wouldnt go just antidepressants without therapy. A lot of people want that, because they seem to think is an amazing happy pill that will solve everything, and that talking is too hard/scary etc. What they dont know is the problem is probably mostly metal and without talking it over, nothing will change long term. And having them together is the most effective.
I wouldnt give antidepressants by them self in most cases. Some psychs/counsellors etc arent the best, but there are good ones out there, who just want to help, many of whom have had serious issues of their own.

one_step_closer 21-08-2007 01:25 PM

As has been said, you can go to your GP who would be likely to offer you medication without counselling if they think that is best for you. But counselling can really help, there's no harm in trying them both. I hope that things go well for you. Please keep us updated and get in touch any time. Take care. xxx

hakoba 22-08-2007 01:19 AM

My opinion is a mixture of what's already been said here.

Yes, it is possible to get antidepressants without attending therapy. I asked for my doctor to put me on some and he did, which I'm grateful for. They've been keeping me out of bad areas a lot more than I was doing on my own before.

But honestly, after sitting down and thinking about it recently, I've realized that I'm never going to get better if I don't talk to someone about it. If you've been traumatized, yes, it's true that the medicine will numb that away. But once you feel good again and you try to stop taking them, soon everything will catch up with you because the trauma is still there.

It's wonderful that you want to get yourself some help. But honestly, make it worth your while if you can and at least do some talking.

hldunbar452 22-08-2007 03:52 AM

Thanks for all your support. After thinking for a very long time i have decided to give it another try and find a psychiatrist. I have the numbers of a couple different places. Hopefully now i will have the courage to call one of them and get the help i really need. Thanks again.

Heather

black_vortex 22-08-2007 12:37 PM

Thats really great and very brave. Please dont give up on them, some are bad, some you have a personal clash with, but there will be someone that is just right for you. Well done - and good on you for thinking and listening.

Trucktastic 22-08-2007 02:13 PM

That is really brave of you, well done.
I hope it works out for you.
In most cases anti-ds work better with counselling, but they don;t have to be prescribed with counselling. I take them, I don't have counselling.

Take care, and good luck

Lozx

The Midnight Crazies 22-08-2007 02:40 PM

A good shrink will do some counseling, too. I tried to do the same and my family dr said she didn't want to diagnose me with something so severe as bipolar and prescribe me lamictal, she said I had to go to a psychiatrist for that, so that all she could do was refer me to one and I said no cuz I never want to set foot in a mental health care center again.

Marte

hldunbar452 23-08-2007 12:35 AM

made an appointment for friday. Thanks for all your help. Wish me luck!

hakoba 23-08-2007 07:26 AM

Good luck and let us know if it works out! I hope this can be a fresh new start towards a better life for you, and remember that we'll always be here for support if you need it. :)

sparkle. 26-08-2007 01:57 PM

good luck!
you'll be fine =]
xx


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:57 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.