![]() |
Is being a part of certain subcultures bad for you?
Are certain subcultures bad for you?
I was thinking a min ago about how I was when I was 15. Back then I would have called myself a Goth...although thinking about it now thats kind of laughable but anyway. I listened to Marilyn Manson and evanescence and Scarling and therefore started to dress like my musical idols. Dressing like this attracted me towards the goth crowed at school and I became one of them. Most of my friends self harmed in some form or another...we all dressed the same, listened to the same music, in some sense being depressed was part of our culture. Sometimes it felt like a competition, to see who could be the most messed up because unless you were the most messed up no one would notice you and no one would help you when you felt bad. I remember many of my friends belittling my problems because theres was worse. They harmed worse then me, the abuse was worse when it happened to them, blah blah blah. About a year and half ago I made a step out of this circle. i felt I was leading my friends behind, I seemed to be growing past them. In the end i met a new group of people from an entirely different scene and I practically cut out my old group of friends and generally the day i did that was the day things started to get better. Although i still have high levels of anxiety. I don't feel as bad as i did and I rarely self harm. It is not the norm to self harm in the culture i am in and as a result maybe i rarely get urges (although sometimes I do, it is never as simple as that). Its kind of the same with some hip hop kids my sister knows. They carry knives and want to be American gangsters. They dress like 50 cent and their other music idols and are blatantly being taken down a bad path by a certain subculture. Of course everyone should be able to dress like they want and listen to what they want. But (and i never would have said this when I was 15) maybe parents are right sometimes to be weary of their kids becoming Goths or hip hop kids...Being a goth was simply not healthy for me, and looking at my friends back then it is obvious that it is not healthy for them either. Ok im loosing track and confusing myself now..... thoughts? |
I do think that subcultures can influence how people act, and can make people do things out of peer pressure or because they want to 'fit in' with a particular group. I think certain people are more affected than others, and it depends on how seriously you take fitting in to sunculture, but I agree that it can be unhealthy.
I think the main one at the moment would be the 'emo' culture. Some teenagers SI, OD and starve themselves because they want to be seen as emo which is unhealthy, especially as they are only doing these things as a kind of fashion statement in a way, and weren't suffering from depression but act like ther are just so they feel part of a subculture. They're my views anyway. |
Are certain subcultures bad for you?
"I was thinking a min ago about how I was when I was 15. Back then I would have called myself a Goth...although thinking about it now thats kind of laughable but anyway. I listened to Marilyn Manson and evanescence and Scarling and therefore started to dress like my musical idols." i think dressing like your music idol and the objects of "subcultures" dont influence people i think it the minority of weird people who are easily impressed by it who are swayed to do exactly as the artists do Dressing like this attracted me towards the goth crowed at school and I became one of them. Most of my friends self harmed in some form or another...we all dressed the same, listened to the same music, in some sense being depressed was part of our culture. Goth subculture is one of rebellion just as punk before it (it was just a darker spin off) and yeah depression seems like a big thing in the Goth community but i would say look at the present and the EMO craze is that going to be our new Goth movement and one which will spawn a new breed of self harmers... i would say it is those who are easily affected and influenced and follow trends who believe that subcultures cause self harm and are bad for you Sometimes it felt like a competition, to see who could be the most messed up because unless you were the most messed up no one would notice you and no one would help you when you felt bad. I remember many of my friends belittling my problems because theres was worse. They harmed worse then me, the abuse was worse when it happened to them, blah blah blah. yeah there is competition in a lot of circles and sometimes that competition can get a bit out of hand About a year and half ago I made a step out of this circle. i felt I was leading my friends behind, I seemed to be growing past them. In the end i met a new group of people from an entirely different scene and I practically cut out my old group of friends and generally the day i did that was the day things started to get better. Although i still have high levels of anxiety. I don't feel as bad as i did and I rarely self harm. It is not the norm to self harm in the culture i am in and as a result maybe i rarely get urges (although sometimes I do, it is never as simple as that). well done for taking a big step and leaving a group that was so triggering and influential to your behaviour Its kind of the same with some hip hop kids my sister knows. They carry knives and want to be American gangsters. They dress like 50 cent and their other music idols and are blatantly being taken down a bad path by a certain subculture. yeah i know hip-hop is a big movement and it does seem like the influencial descisions are made by the artists people follow and there does seem to be a lot of things about the hip hop craze (and the trouble) Of course everyone should be able to dress like they want and listen to what they want. But (and i never would have said this when I was 15) maybe parents are right sometimes to be weary of their kids becoming Goths or hip hop kids...Being a goth was simply not healthy for me, and looking at my friends back then it is obvious that it is not healthy for them either. Ok im loosing track and confusing myself now..... and in closing yes subcultures can be bad for you but it all just depends on how influenced by famous people you are and parants find the stereotypes and take it from there so i would say some times it is not justified to worry but some times it can be peace love and good happiness stuff STEVE |
Maybe its more down to people attitudes of what these "subcultures" entail. Its true that more so called goths and emos cut, but then people have this atitde that because you are like that you are going to to be all doom and gloom and cut and think about suicde all the time. Its simply not like this and it implies to many of the subcultures
Right now i still listen to the goth music dress like that a bit, but thats because of what im into and what i like, im not going to change because people think "ohh emo, cutter, depressed" |
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:17 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.